Meet Jeanne!
1. Tell us about your personal breastfeeding experience with your child:
When my first son was born, I knew I wanted to breastfeed – I just underestimated how much of a challenge it would be in the beginning. I probably didn’t sleep for the first five days of his life – a combination of him waking up, and me being freaked out because I couldn’t get it to “work” right. As soon as I could, I made an appointment with our local breastfeeding support center and I literally counted the hours until my appointment. When I walked into the office, I burst into tears – the culmination of all of my frustration and exhaustion.
But they gave me lots of help, and so much encouragement, and I left feeling like, “I can do this.” Within a day or two he was nursing much better, and we never looked back.
When he was four months old, I went back to work four days a week, and I pumped religiously. It was so much work. I think if I had been in a less supportive workplace I would have given up on it much sooner. By about 8 months, I stopped pumping and he started having formula while I was at work. But I kept nursing him in the morning and at night, and it was a very sweet time for both of us.
My second baby was a preemie and lived in the NICU for the first three weeks of his life. He was born too little to coordinate sucking and swallowing so he basically had to learn to eat. First they had him on a feeding tube, and then they fed him from these tiny little bottles. I pumped around the clock and ferried the bottles back and forth to the hospital. I worried that he would become a bottle baby and not be interested in nursing.
But this time I was smarter. I went straight to the breastfeeding support center as soon as he came home. (You’d think that I’d be an expert the second time around, but it was almost like I had to learn it all over again.) Again, they were a great help – and soon he wanted nothing to do with the bottles.
2. What is your view of breastfeeding in public, and why?
I’m a pretty modest person so I didn’t do it much, especially as the babies got bigger. If I needed to do it, I definitely covered myself up. But I have no problem with women doing it. It’s food for the baby.
3. What is your view of sustained breastfeeding, and why?
I nursed both of my kids until they were a little older than two, and I loved every single minute of it.
I had this preconception of a mom who did sustained breastfeeding as some sort of barefoot hippie type with naked kids clinging to her from all sides. That’s just not me. But once I started nursing, I really didn’t want to stop – it was so incredibly sweet, and the time became even sweeter as my babies turned in to toddlers. Just thinking about that time makes me all misty-eyed.
I certainly would never push it on anyone. And I wasn’t in-your-face about it; after the first year I was only nursing at home, in the early morning or at bedtime. But I would encourage new moms to tune out prejudices and keep their minds open to doing it if it feels right. For me and my little ones, it was definitely the right thing.
4.Is there anything you find unique about your breastfeeding story with your child?
I’m proud of the fact that I was able to continue nursing my older one even after I went back to work. And I’m proud of the fact that I brought my younger one home from the NICU as a bottle-feeding baby and turned him into an exclusively nursing baby.
5. Is there anything you wish you did differently?
I wish I hadn’t taken negative words so seriously. People would say things like, “If you nurse them to sleep, they’ll never learn to sleep on their own.” Well, I did nurse them to sleep, and they learned to sleep on their own just fine. Or people would say, “If your newborn baby gets used to drinking from a bottle, he’ll never learn to nurse.” That’s just plain untrue. Babies and kids are incredibly flexible. They can learn anything. My advice would be not to get stuck in the “never” mindset.
Also, I wish I hadn’t been so affected by the stigma against sustained nursing. I pretty much did it at home, at night and in the early mornings, but there were some people who knew I was still nursing who would tut-tut about the whole thing. I wish I could have been better at ignoring them and feeling more confident about my decisions. In the end, I really believe that the amount of time I nursed – and the point at which I weaned them – was just right for me and both of my kids.
6. Is there anything you’d like to add?
Moms have it tough. You get judged if you don’t nurse at all or if you don’t do it for long enough; you get judged if you nurse too long. I wish people could just kind of lay off the whole debate and just focus on how sweet – and important – the time really is. If it feels like you’re doing the right thing, you probably are.
Jeanne Fratello writes The Jolly Tomato, a blog about kids’ nutrition.










What a great series. I could have used this resource during my breastfeeding nightmares like major.
It’s funny, before kids I would have thought this topic to be TMI. But after kids, you find that you are totally comfortable talking about your labor experience, your breasts, your uterus, poop… no topic is off the table! I breast fed all 3 of my kids. I was shy with the first, keeping extra care to stay covered in public. Then, the third, your attitude changes to “What? If they didn’t the nipple – who cares?!” Women have been breast feeding for centuries, so to see this topic is taboo is ridiculous!
This is so great, thanks for sharing.
I only nursed both my girls until they were around 7 months. I was happy I went as long as I did, especially since I had a very hard time with my first. I would have liked to go longer though, thinking back on it.
I think you have a very healthy attitude about it. So many people let the comments of others influence how they handle their kids.
I remember worrying about that “don’t nurse to sleep thing” because my little guy was (and still is) a breast milk addict. But lo and behold he learned to sleep on his own too. There are so many things we have figured out together just by doing it.
Thank you for sharing this, Jeanne. I had the hardest time nursing my first son. We had a lactation consultant come over to our house to help me and she ended up giving my baby a cold. The cold turned into bronchiolitis and at 5 weeks he was admitted to children’s hospital and stayed there for a week. During that week we finally got a handle on the nursing routine. Man, that was not an easy time.
I love these stories. They’re very eye-opening for a judgmental she-witch like me. Thanks!
Great interview! I struggled so with nursing two of my three breastfed kids and fell prey to all the usual “all or nothing” type messages. I wish I’d been easier on myself!
I had a very difficult experience and it was because all consultants made me feel in adequate for not getting it . It was finally he 3rd physician who supported the choice to o to a bottle at 3 months with a screaming chile. Let’s say I did not wait that long with number 2
great way to share someone else’s experience!
What a great article!! Thank you so much for sharing!
This is probably one of my favorite series. What you are doing to promote breastfeeding…to normalize it…it’s incredible…..
Love these breast feeding series.